This development comes after the Bombay High Court clarified last week that it had not ordered the closure of kabutarkhanas — the decision had been taken by the BMC based on public health concerns. Following this clarification, advocates from the Jain community formally requested that the BMC reopen pigeon feeding spots. As of Monday, however, all kabutarkhanas remain shut. Meanwhile, some BJP MLAs have also been pressing the municipal corporation to restore them.
Dadar civic activist Chetan Kamble criticized the way the matter has been handled, stating, “Last week, certain members of the Jain community demanded that the Kabutar Khana be reopened. Now, on August 13, members of the Marathi community are marching to ensure it stays closed. What should have been a straightforward task — enforcing court rulings and safeguarding public health — has now turned into a community-versus-community spectacle. This is not about Jains versus Marathis; it is about whether laws are applied equally to everyone. While people are split along community lines, those breaking the law carry on without consequences. Mumbai doesn’t need communal squabbles — it needs collective action for cleaner, healthier public spaces.”
Third FIR for pigeon feeding in just over a week
In a related incident, an FIR was lodged in Girgaon against an unidentified person caught feeding pigeons on Monday. The complaint was filed after a video surfaced showing the individual scattering grains at Girgaon Chowpatty. This marks the third FIR in eight days over similar violations.
The earlier cases included one registered at Mahim police station against an unidentified person for feeding pigeons and another at Shivaji Park police station against Lalbaug resident Mahendra Sanclecha, 55. In that case, Sanclecha allegedly arrived at Dadar Kabutar Khana with a food grain tray fixed to the roof of his car, deliberately feeding the pigeons in defiance of the ban.
For now, the stand-off continues — with public health advocates demanding strict enforcement, pigeon feeders challenging the restrictions, and political groups stepping into the fray, ensuring that what began as a civic health measure has escalated into a full-blown political and social confrontation.